CFB Rooting Guide
Methodology

The Mid-American title race

Updated November 22, after week 11, from 2.5 million simulated seasons.

Who wins the Mid-American
  1. Western Michigan30.8%
  2. Toledo27.4%
  3. Buffalo22.8%
  4. Ohio19.0%
TeamConfOverallTitle gameWins Mid-AmericanPlayoff
6-18-356.0%30.8%<0.1%
6-19-248.3%27.4%<0.1%
6-18-356.4%22.8%<0.1%
6-18-339.4%19.0%<0.1%
1-62-90.0%0.0%<0.1%
2-53-80.0%0.0%<0.1%
3-43-80.0%0.0%<0.1%
3-45-60.0%0.0%<0.1%
3-44-70.0%0.0%<0.1%
2-53-80.0%0.0%<0.1%
2-55-60.0%0.0%<0.1%
5-27-40.0%0.0%<0.1%
1-72-90.0%0.0%<0.1%

Mid-American clinching scenarios

In, whatever else happensNeeds helpOut

TeamNowWins out1 loss
Western MichiganWMU6-17-16-2
Needs help even if it wins out. At 7-1: in with Buffalo losing to Akron; or with Ohio losing to Toledo.
Every scenario
  1. 7-1Wins out
    In with Buffalo losing to Akron; or with Ohio losing to Toledo.
    How the ties go:
    • InLevel with Buffalo and Toledotiebreakers
    • OutLevel with Buffalo and Ohiobest common opponent: Ohio 1-0, Western Michigan 0-1
  2. 6-21 loss
    In with Buffalo losing to Akron and Ohio losing to Toledo. It can also get in if a tie reaches the last step.
    How the ties go:
ToledoTOL6-17-16-2
Needs help even if it wins out. At 7-1: in with Buffalo losing to Akron; or with Western Michigan losing to Miami (OH).
Every scenario
  1. 7-1Wins out
    In with Buffalo losing to Akron; or with Western Michigan losing to Miami (OH).
    How the ties go:
  2. 6-21 loss
    In only through a tiebreaker.
BuffaloBUFF6-17-16-2
Needs help even if it wins out. At 7-1: in with Toledo losing to Ohio; or with Western Michigan losing to Miami (OH).
Every scenario
  1. 7-1Wins out
    In with Toledo losing to Ohio; or with Western Michigan losing to Miami (OH).
    How the ties go:
  2. 6-21 loss
    In only through a tiebreaker.
OhioOHIO6-17-16-2
Clinches with a win over Toledo.
Every scenario
  1. 7-1Wins out
    In, on tiebreakers.
  2. 6-21 loss
    Out.

Out of the race: Akron, Ball State, Bowling Green, Central Michigan, Eastern Michigan, Kent State, Massachusetts, Miami (OH) and Sacramento State.

Likeliest title games

  1. 33.6% of seasonsToledoTOL52%48%Western MichiganWMU
  2. 29.3% of seasonsOhioOHIO52%48%BuffaloBUFF
  3. 13.8% of seasonsToledoTOL68%32%BuffaloBUFF
  4. 13.2% of seasonsWestern MichiganWMU67%33%BuffaloBUFF
  5. 9.2% of seasonsWestern MichiganWMU63%37%OhioOHIO
  6. 0.8% of seasonsToledoTOL60%40%OhioOHIO

The games that decide the race

  1. 1ToledoatOhioWeek 130.62Most at stakeOhio100.0Toledo76.1Western Michigan53.8
  2. 2BuffaloatAkronWeek 130.29Most at stakeBuffalo75.5Western Michigan54.6Toledo20.8
  3. 3Miami (OH)atWestern MichiganWeek 130.20Most at stakeWestern Michigan48.0Buffalo26.3Toledo21.8
  4. 4Central MichiganatBall StateWeek 130.11Most at stakeToledo23.2Buffalo21.0Western Michigan2.3
  5. 5MassachusettsatBowling GreenWeek 130.07Most at stakeBuffalo14.4Toledo14.3Ohio0.1
  6. 6Kent StateatEastern MichiganWeek 130.04Most at stakeToledo10.1Buffalo8.9Western Michigan1.2

Mid-American tiebreaker rules

The two teams with the best conference winning percentage meet in the title game. It is played at a neutral site.

  1. Head-to-headRecord in games among the tied teams. If they have not all played each other, a team that beat all the others goes through and a team that lost to all of them drops out.
  2. Common opponentsRecord against the conference opponents all the tied teams played.
  3. Best common opponentRecord against the highest-placed common opponent, then the next, down the standings until one team is ahead. Opponents level in the standings count as one.
  4. Opponents' recordCombined conference winning percentage of each team's conference opponents.
  5. SportSource ratingSportSource Analytics' team rating score after the regular season. A draw by the commissioner follows if still level.
  • Two teams level at the top both go, and no step is needed.
  • A tie for a spot runs through the steps until one team is left. It takes the spot, and the rest start again for the next one.
  • When a step cuts a tie to two teams, they start again at step 1. Three or more left go on to the next step.

SportSource rating cannot be known until the regular season ends, so a team is only called in on this page when it does not depend on it.

If the season ended today

Buffalo and Western Michigan

Tied at 6-1 for the first spot: Buffalo, Ohio, Toledo and Western Michigan

  1. Head-to-headThey have not all played each other, and no team beat all the others.
  2. Common opponentsStill level.
  3. Best common opponentStill level.
  4. Opponents' recordBuffalo .551Ohio .344Toledo .467Western Michigan .490Buffalo takes the spot.

Tied at 6-1 for the second spot: Ohio, Toledo and Western Michigan

  1. Head-to-headThey have not all played each other, and no team beat all the others.
  2. Common opponentsOhio 1-0Toledo 1-0Western Michigan 1-0Still level.
  3. Best common opponentStill level.
  4. Opponents' recordOhio .344Toledo .467Western Michigan .490Western Michigan takes the spot.

Questions

Who is favored to win the Mid-American in 2026?
Western Michigan wins the Mid-American in 30.8% of simulated seasons, ahead of Toledo (27.4%) and Buffalo (22.8%).
Who will play in the Mid-American championship game?
The likeliest pairing is Toledo against Western Michigan, in 33.6% of seasons. Toledo reaches the game in 48.3% and Western Michigan in 56.0%.
How does the Mid-American break ties for its championship game?
The two teams with the best conference winning percentage meet in the title game. It is played at a neutral site. Ties are broken by head-to-head, then common opponents, then best common opponent, then opponents' record, then SportSource rating.
How many Mid-American teams will make the College Football Playoff?
0.0 on average across the simulated seasons. Toledo makes it in <0.1%, Western Michigan makes it in <0.1%, Buffalo makes it in <0.1%.

Other conferences: ACC American Athletic Big 12 Big Ten Conference USA Mountain West Pac-12 SEC Sun Belt

Back to the guide